Western Digital MyBook Premium Edition 500GB External Hard Drive

More on this product: review; user reviews; specifications; compare; shop

Share
- Digg
- Del.icio.us
- Reddit
- Facebook
E-mail
Print

CNET editors' rating: 3.5 stars Very good
Detailed editors' rating

Average user rating: 2.0 stars out of 57 reviews
See all user reviews

Product summary

The good: The MyBook Premium edition is compact, employs an innovative design, has an external capacity gauge, comes with backup software, and is a speedy data reader.

The bad The bad: The MyBook Premium edition is slow to write data, over both USB 2.0 and FireWire 400.

The bottom line: If write speed isn't a top priority, the Western Digital MyBook is a good deal at around $300 for a 500GB drive. It'll look good on your desk or bookshelf, too.

Specifications: Compatibility: PC, Mac; Connector type: 6 pin FireWire, 4 pin USB Type B; Hard drive size: 500 GB; See full specs

Price range: $119.95 - $168.12

See all products in the My Book Premium Edition series

CNET editors' review

Reviewed by: Dong Van Ngo
Edited by: Felisa Yang
Reviewed on: 06/15/2006
Released on: 03/08/2006

The Western Digital MyBook Premium Edition external hard drive is physically portable but still humongous in terms of capacity. The 500GB unit we tested offered the most mixed performance of any external hard drive we've tested. Though we love its design, capacity, and small size, we were a little disappointed with its overall performance. Direct competitors in this space include the Maxtor OneTouch III Basic (500GB), the Seagate Pushbutton Backup Drive (400GB), and the Iomega External Hard Drive (400GB). All these drives cost about the same, though the Iomega also offers FireWire 800 connections. All have backup software, as well. The Seagate drive was a slow performer, while the Iomega was speedy when transferring over FireWire but slow over USB 2.0.

Drive type: external hard disk drive
Available capacities: 160GB; 250GB; 320GB; 400GB; 500GB--all drives have a 7,200rpm hard disk drive
Capacity of test unit: 500GB
Cache: 16MB for the 400GB and 500GB drives; 8MB for the rest
Dimension: 6.8 x 5.6 x 2.2 (HLD in inches); 2.6 pounds
Notable design features: backup button; book-like design
Connection options: FireWire 400, USB 2.0
OSs supported: Windows 98 SE/Me/2000/XP or, Mac OS X 10.2.8+
Software included: EMC Retrospect Express Backup and System Recovery Software (on drive)
Additional features: capacity gauge: the backup button features an LED that indicates how much space is available on your drive; the drive turns itself off when not in use
Service/support: one-year warranty; toll-free phone support: 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. from Monday through Thursday, 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Friday, and 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. CT on Saturday; e-mail support via an online form; Web site has a searchable knowledge base, FAQs, downloadable drivers, and software.

On CNET Labs' test bench, the 500GB MyBook was very sluggish when writing, via both FireWire 400 and USB 2.0 connections. The drive took almost 36 minutes to write our 10GB test folder, about three times slower than other hard drives with the same specs. On the other hand, in the read test, the MyBook drive took slightly less than 10 minutes to get the job done, which was the fastest among all of the external hard drives we've tested.

The Western Digital MyBook comes in a very sleek design that is shaped like a medium-size book and weighs about the same. It features a button in front that activates the bundled Retrospect backup software. The coolest thing about the MyBook drive is that the button has a round, blue LED ring around it that indicates the amount of space available on the hard drive.

See more CNET content tagged:: Western Digital,; external hard drive,; Iomega Corp.,; FireWire,; Seagate Technology

User reviews

Average user rating: 2.0 stars out of 57 reviews
My rating: 0 stars Write review

Showing 5 of 57 user reviewsSee all 57 user reviews
4.0 stars

47 out of 47 people found this review helpful

"If you want speed, reformat the disc as NTFS"

by mdobson1 on February 9, 2007

read more
1.0 stars

39 out of 47 people found this review helpful

"Western Digital Confirms HUGE Problems"

by Pleonexia on April 6, 2006

read more
4.5 stars

16 out of 18 people found this review helpful

"Sleek, Slim, and Sexy for an External Hard Drive"

by bigb177 on June 14, 2006

read more
4.0 stars

8 out of 8 people found this review helpful

"Works very well, it does the job"

by Artur.AN on January 5, 2007

read more
3.5 stars

8 out of 8 people found this review helpful

"500gb for $199 at BestBuy til I think 07/29/06"

by Saltiva on July 26, 2006

read more
See all 57 user reviews Write review

Submit your review

Western Digital MyBook Premium Edition 500GB External Hard Drive

1. Rate this product:: (Mouse over the stars to rate this product and click to set your rating.)
2. One-line summary:(Summarize your review in one line. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 55 characters
3. Pros:(Tell us what you like about this product. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 250 characters
4. Cons:(Tell us what you don't like about this product. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 250 characters
Bottom-line summary:(Explain to us in detail why you like or dislike the product, focusing your comments on the product's features and functionality, and your experience using the product. This field is optional.): 0 of 5000 characters; Submit